← All articles BUYER GUIDE

How to Evaluate a Google SEO Ranking Guarantee

Ask the agency to commit to work you can verify and explain how it will report results. Google says nobody can guarantee a #1 ranking. Google’s guide to hiring an SEO

A forecast can help you decide whether a project is worth funding. A service commitment can give you a way to accept completed work. Ask the supplier to put each in its own part of the proposal, with an owner and a review date.

SEO proposal review checklist covering scope, acceptance and reporting

Diagram by Meridian SEO.

Get the ranking promise in writing

Suppose a proposal offers “10 page-one keywords in 90 days.” Before you price it against another bid, ask which ten searches qualify and which pages should appear. Agree on the target country, language, device, search type and measurement dates. Keep a record of the original list and agree how changes will be approved.

Check whether the supplier counts a single observation, repeated observations or an average. A page shown once on a mobile search in one location tells you little about how often buyers in your market saw it. Ask how branded terms, local map results and sponsored listings are handled. Google says advertising has no effect on a site’s organic rankings. Google’s hiring guidance

If the supplier offers a refund or credit, ask which fee it covers and what evidence triggers it. The terms should say who owns the data, who checks the result and what happens if either side changes the target list or delays a release. Ask for the planned methods too, especially when the agency wants permission to change your site or place links. Backlink review guide

Review an example in Search Console

Ask the supplier to walk through a redacted report from an engagement with a similar market or website. Then use your own Search Console property to agree on a baseline. Write down the query or query group, page, country, device, date range and search type. Keep those settings with each export so a colleague can repeat the comparison.

Search Console’s average position reflects the average position of the highest result from the site or group being reported. It can differ from what you see in a manual search. Look at impressions and clicks alongside position so you can see whether a movement concerns a meaningful slice of demand. Keep inquiries, demos or trials in a separate analytics or CRM report, with a documented conversion definition. Google’s Performance report documentation

Replace a ranking clause with an acceptance test

Here is an example scope for a manufacturer rebuilding a product catalogue. The numbers describe proposed work for one market. The buyer and supplier would agree the final scope before starting.

Milestone Supplier commitment Buyer’s acceptance check
Baseline Review 8 priority URLs and map each to a buying query group. Save an export covering the 28 days before implementation. The team can reproduce the export and explain which page should answer each query group.
Implementation Prepare changes for 2 agreed templates. Record who approves the edits, who deploys them and which URLs changed. Review the deployed pages against the ticket. Check HTTP status, canonical, index directives and internal links on the agreed URLs.
Follow-up Retest the affected pages and compare the first complete 28-day reporting window with the baseline. Document release delays, seasonal factors and remaining issues. Verify the live changes and review the filtered impressions, clicks and qualified RFQs separately. Use the findings to decide the next work order.

Use URL Inspection to distinguish what Google indexed from what its live test can fetch. A successful live test supports the technical handoff. Google still decides whether and where the page appears. Google’s URL Inspection guidance

Compare suppliers on the same brief

Give each supplier one priority market, the same URLs and a buyer action that matters. Ask for a price, delivery owner, expected review date and example of the work you would receive. Use the SEO RFP template or narrow the brief with our guide to choosing an affordable SEO service.

For a Chinese-language perspective on ranking promises when buying an export website, see YT Captain’s article on Google keyword ranking guarantees.